Living in Murray Hill Jacksonville: What to Know Before You Move

Housing and Home Prices in Murray Hill

Murray Hill's housing stock is predominantly single-family homes built between 1920 and 1960, with a mix of bungalows, ranch-style homes, and occasional mid-century modern structures. The median home price in Murray Hill ranges from $285,000 to $385,000 as of early 2026, though you'll find listings from the mid-$200s to over $500,000 depending on condition and location.

The most desirable streets run perpendicular to the river—particularly anything between Edgewood Avenue and Riverside Avenue. These blocks offer mature oak canopy, larger lots, and proximity to the St. Johns River. Homes closer to Roosevelt Boulevard tend to be more affordable but come with increased traffic noise and less walkable access to amenities.

Renovation is common here. Many buyers purchase unrenovated homes in the $250,000–$300,000 range and invest $50,000–$100,000 in updates. Original hardwood floors, brick fireplaces, and large yards are standard features that attract buyers willing to do the work. If you're looking at buying your first home in Jacksonville, Murray Hill offers relatively affordable entry points compared to neighboring Avondale or Riverside.

Rental properties are also prevalent—about 40% of Murray Hill residents rent rather than own. Single-family rentals range from $1,600 to $2,400 per month, while smaller homes and duplexes start around $1,200.

Walkability and Getting Around

Murray Hill's Walk Score sits around 62—somewhat walkable, but a car helps. The northern section near Edgewood Avenue and Post Street offers the best pedestrian access to local businesses, coffee shops, and restaurants. You can walk to Fishweeds, Bold Bean Coffee, and several local bars and eateries from most homes north of Seminole Road.

The southern portion closer to Roosevelt Boulevard is less walkable. Sidewalks are inconsistent, traffic moves fast, and distances between residential streets and commercial areas make daily errands on foot impractical. Most residents drive to Publix (about 1.5 miles west on Roosevelt) or the Riverside Arts Market on weekends.

Bike infrastructure is minimal—sharrows exist on Edgewood, but no protected lanes. If you're biking to nearby Five Points or Riverside, expect to share lanes with cars. The Riverside/Avondale Greenway project has been discussed for years but remains incomplete as of 2026.

Parking is easy. Nearly every home has a driveway or garage, and street parking is unrestricted in residential areas.

Dining, Coffee, and Local Businesses

Murray Hill's commercial corridor along Edgewood Avenue and Post Street is the neighborhood's biggest draw. You'll find locally owned spots like Fishweeds (seafood and oysters), Hawkers Asian Street Food, Strings Sports Brewery, and Bold Bean Coffee Roasters. These aren't hidden gems—they're busy, especially on weekends.

The food scene leans casual. No fine dining, but solid options for tacos, burgers, ramen, and pub food. Sunday brunch at Fishweeds or Hawkers typically requires a wait. If you want more variety, Riverside and Avondale are five minutes away.

Small businesses and service providers cluster near Post Street—yoga studios, dog grooming, auto repair, and a few boutique shops. It's not a retail destination, but you can handle most errands locally. The nearest full grocery store is Publix on Roosevelt or Trader Joe's in Riverside.

Murray Hill also has a growing brewery presence. Strings Sports Brewery and Aardwolf Brewing both operate taprooms here, and Bold City Brewery is just across the river in Riverside.

Schools and Family Considerations

Murray Hill sits in Duval County Public Schools. The zoned elementary school is John Stockton Elementary, middle schoolers attend Landon Middle School, and the high school is Robert E. Lee High School (currently in the process of being renamed following community input).

Test scores for these schools fall below county averages, which is why many families with school-age children opt for private schools or magnet programs. Nearby private options include Riverside Presbyterian Day School (Pre-K–8) and The Bolles School, both in neighboring areas.

Murray Hill isn't heavily family-oriented compared to suburbs like Nocatee or Southside neighborhoods. You'll see families here, especially on the quieter residential streets, but the neighborhood skews younger—singles, couples, and young professionals dominate. Playgrounds and parks are limited. The nearest substantial green space is Memorial Park in Riverside, about a 10-minute drive.

If schools are a priority and you want to stay in the urban core, San Marco and parts of Riverside offer better-rated zoned schools while maintaining walkability and historic character.

Safety and Public Safety Resources

Safety is a personal priority for every buyer, and Murray Hill is no different from any urban neighborhood in that respect—doing your own research for specific streets and blocks matters. The Murray Hill Preservation Association maintains an active neighborhood watch program and community communication network where residents stay connected on local issues.

Like any urban neighborhood, standard precautions are widely practiced here: locking vehicles, using motion-sensor lighting, and doorbell cameras are common among residents. The neighborhood has an active community presence, and neighbors tend to look out for one another.

For current public safety data, visit the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office or search your address on CrimeMapping.com. These tools let you review activity at the specific address or block level, which is far more useful than neighborhood-wide generalizations when making a home purchase decision.

Who Murray Hill Is Best For

Murray Hill works well for buyers who want urban living without paying Riverside or Avondale prices. If you're comfortable with renovation projects, have a reliable car, and prioritize local coffee shops and restaurants over top-rated schools, this neighborhood makes sense.

It's popular with young professionals, remote workers, and couples in their late 20s to early 40s. The bar and restaurant scene attracts people who want to walk to weekend hangouts but don't need nightlife every evening. Investors also target Murray Hill for rental properties—cash flow is decent, and appreciation has been steady as Murray Hill and Riverside continue to see development momentum.

Murray Hill is not ideal for families prioritizing schools, buyers who don't want to deal with home repairs, or anyone expecting a polished, amenity-rich suburban lifestyle. It's a transitional neighborhood—improving, but not fully arrived.

If you're comparing it to other urban neighborhoods, Murray Hill is grittier than Avondale, more affordable than Riverside, and more established than Springfield. You're buying into potential, not perfection.