Murray Hill School Zones: Which Schools Actually Serve the Neighborhood
Murray Hill doesn't have a single elementary school that serves the entire neighborhood. The majority of Murray Hill students attend John Stockton Elementary School, located at 4524 College Street, directly within the neighborhood. Stockton serves grades PK-5 and enrolls approximately 450 students.
A smaller section of eastern Murray Hill, closer to College Street and I-10, falls into the West Riverside Elementary School zone. Homes south of Edgewood Avenue near Park Street may be zoned for Fishweir Elementary School. Before making an offer on any Murray Hill property, verify the exact school assignment with Duval County Public Schools using the property's full street address—zoning lines can shift block by block.
For middle school, most Murray Hill students are assigned to Kirby-Smith Middle School at 1012 San Juan Avenue in San Marco, about a 10-minute drive. High school students typically attend Robert E. Lee High School at 1200 S McDuff Avenue, located just west of Murray Hill near the Roosevelt area.
Parents should also check eligibility for magnet programs like those at Riverside Presbyterian Day School (private, not DCPS), Paxon School for Advanced Studies, and Douglas Anderson School of the Arts—all accessible from Murray Hill with reasonable commutes.
John Stockton Elementary: Test Scores, Enrollment, and What Parents Say
John Stockton Elementary received a C grade from the Florida Department of Education for the 2023-2024 school year. The school serves a diverse student body with approximately 52% economically disadvantaged students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch programs.
In the most recent state assessments, Stockton's proficiency rates were:
- Reading: 50% of students scored proficient or above (compared to 53% statewide)
- Math: 54% proficient (compared to 56% statewide)
- Science: 46% proficient (compared to 51% statewide)
The school operates a traditional calendar with approximately 18 students per teacher, slightly below the Duval County average. Stockton offers after-school programs through the city's KidsZone initiative and has an active PTA that organizes fundraisers and campus improvements.
Many Murray Hill parents praise the school's neighborhood feel and tight-knit community involvement. Others supplement with tutoring or consider private school options like Hendricks Avenue Elementary (private), which serves families across Jacksonville's urban core. If you're considering investment properties in nearby Springfield, similar school considerations apply—check out why investors are buying in Springfield Jacksonville right now for rental market context.
Kirby-Smith Middle School and Lee High School: What to Expect
Kirby-Smith Middle School serves grades 6-8 with about 750 students and received a B grade in the 2023-2024 school year. Located in the San Marco neighborhood, the school offers advanced coursework and has a reputation for strong arts programs. Parent feedback generally highlights supportive teachers and a structured environment, though class sizes can be large—averaging 22-25 students per core class.
Robert E. Lee High School enrolls approximately 1,400 students and received a B grade for 2023-2024. Lee offers International Baccalaureate (IB) diploma programs, Advanced Placement (AP) courses, dual enrollment with Florida State College at Jacksonville, and career-technical education pathways including culinary arts and automotive technology.
Lee's four-year graduation rate sits at 89%, slightly above the Duval County average of 87%. The school's strengths include its IB program and athletic programs, particularly football and track. Families looking for smaller class sizes or specialized academics often explore magnet schools like Paxon (rated A) or Douglas Anderson (rated A), both of which accept students districtwide through lottery or audition processes.
If you're weighing Murray Hill against other Jacksonville neighborhoods, check the Murray Hill Jacksonville property taxes guide to understand how school funding and millage rates affect your annual costs.
Private and Charter School Options Accessible From Murray Hill
Murray Hill's location puts families within 15 minutes of several highly rated private and charter schools:
- Riverside Presbyterian Day School (PreK-6): Located in Riverside, this independent day school consistently ranks among Jacksonville's top private elementary programs, with tuition around $14,000-$18,000 annually.
- Bishop Kenny High School (9-12): Catholic college-prep school with strong academics and athletics, tuition approximately $15,000/year. Located in Arlington, about 15 minutes from Murray Hill.
- The Bolles School (PreK-12): Jacksonville's most prestigious private school with campuses in Riverside (lower school) and on the Southside. Tuition ranges from $20,000-$28,000 depending on grade level.
- KIPP Impact Middle School: Tuition-free public charter school in Springfield with extended school days and a college-prep focus. Lottery-based admissions.
Charter school enrollment typically opens in January for the following school year, with lotteries held in February or March. Private schools have rolling admissions but fill spots quickly—many families apply 12-18 months before their desired start date.
Parents moving from St. Augustine often ask how school quality compares. While St. Augustine has fewer magnet options, some families prefer the smaller district size. Read more in our cost of living comparison between St. Augustine and Jacksonville.
School Assignment Verification and Rezoning Risk
Duval County Public Schools redraws attendance boundaries periodically to balance enrollment and accommodate new developments. The last major redistricting affecting Murray Hill occurred in 2019, when some homes near I-10 shifted from Fishweir Elementary to West Riverside Elementary.
Before closing on any Murray Hill home, verify current school assignments using the Duval County Public Schools Attendance Zone Finder at dcps.duvalschools.org. Enter the full property address—not just the street name—because zoning can change mid-block.
If a property is listed as being in a specific school zone, confirm it in writing with your agent and double-check with DCPS directly. Real estate listings sometimes use outdated information, and boundary changes aren't always reflected immediately in MLS data.
Families buying specifically for school access should also understand that grandfathering policies vary. If your child is already enrolled at a school and your address is rezoned, Duval County typically allows them to finish the school year—but not necessarily continue through all grade levels. Siblings may not automatically qualify for the same grandfathered assignment.
For investors evaluating Murray Hill properties, school zones matter even if you're not raising kids yourself. Homes in higher-rated school zones typically rent faster and command higher rents, especially among families relocating to Jacksonville for work.
How Murray Hill Schools Compare to Other Jacksonville Neighborhoods
Murray Hill's school assignments fall in the middle tier among Jacksonville's urban core neighborhoods. For comparison:
- San Marco families attend Hendricks Avenue Elementary (A-rated, private) or San Marco Elementary (B-rated, public) and the same Kirby-Smith Middle and Lee High as Murray Hill.
- Riverside and Avondale families typically attend Riverside Presbyterian Day School (private) or Fishweir Elementary (C-rated), with similar middle and high school options.
- Ortega families have access to Ortega Elementary (B-rated) and Landon Middle School (A-rated), often considered stronger than Murray Hill's default assignments. Learn more about Ortega's advantages in our Ortega Jacksonville river homes guide.
Many Murray Hill families prioritize the neighborhood's affordability and character over school ratings, then supplement with tutoring, magnet programs, or private school. The trade-off often works for buyers who want walkable, historic charm without paying San Marco or Ortega premiums—Murray Hill's median home price sits around $285,000 compared to $450,000+ in Ortega.
If schools are a dealbreaker, consider expanding your search to neighborhoods with A-rated elementary zones like Mandarin or Nocatee on the Southside, though you'll sacrifice Murray Hill's urban character and quick commute times. Check out Murray Hill's commute times for comparison.
Agent's take: I always tell buyers with school-age kids to tour the actual schools before making an offer—ratings don't capture teacher quality, class culture, or whether your kid will thrive there. Visit during pickup time, talk to parents in the carpool line, and trust your gut as much as the data.
Frequently Asked Questions
What elementary school serves Murray Hill Jacksonville?
Most Murray Hill homes are zoned for John Stockton Elementary at 4524 College Street, but some eastern sections attend West Riverside Elementary and some southern areas attend Fishweir Elementary. Verify your exact address with Duval County Public Schools before buying.
Are Murray Hill Jacksonville schools highly rated?
John Stockton Elementary received a C grade from the state, Kirby-Smith Middle School earned a B, and Robert E. Lee High School earned a B for 2023-2024. These are mid-tier ratings compared to Jacksonville's top-performing schools, but many families supplement with magnet programs or private schools.
Can Murray Hill families apply for magnet schools?
Yes. Murray Hill residents can apply to any Duval County magnet school, including Paxon School for Advanced Studies, Douglas Anderson School of the Arts, and Riverside Fine Arts Elementary. Applications open in January, and most programs use lottery-based admissions.
Do school zones affect Murray Hill home values?
Yes. Homes in higher-rated school zones typically sell faster and rent for more, even in the same neighborhood. If you're buying for investment or planning to sell within a few years, verify school assignments and consider proximity to magnet schools that increase buyer appeal.
Buying in Murray Hill? Let's Talk Schools and Resale Value
School assignments change, and MLS data isn't always current. I'll verify zoning for any property you're considering, walk you through magnet school options, and help you understand how schools affect long-term value—whether you have kids or you're buying as an investment. Let's make sure you're buying in the right zone.
Get In Touch →